Henry Stark’s “Bird’s Eye View of Dallas” — 1895/96
by Paula Bosse
Commerce St. looking east from about Akard (click for larger image)
by Paula Bosse
In the winter of 1895-1896, a St. Louis photographer named Henry Stark traveled to Texas, photographing scenes and vistas across the state. According to The Handbook of Texas, he is believed to be “the first photographer to have made an extensive photographic record of Texas.” A collection of his photos was published under the title Views in Texas.
The photograph above shows Commerce Street looking east, with the post office and its tall clock tower dominating the scene (the clock shows that it is 9:35 in the morning). The Old Post Office was bounded by Main, Ervay, Commerce, and St. Paul.
This is a great photo, showing Dallas as I’ve never seen it before. I’ve zoomed in to see the “hidden” details. (All photos are much larger when clicked.)
What is the building on the left? It’s very unusual-looking. (UPDATE: See the comments below. This appears to be the adjoining Bookhout and Middleton Buildings at Ervay and Main.)
This is my favorite detail. All that trash. And vacant lots. And a haphazard, meandering fence. Are those steps leading to rear entrances of buildings facing Main? And those utility poles! That block looks kind of squalid. Not Dallas at its best. I think this would be around Akard. (UPDATE: A reader wrote to say that this looks like a “ravine” — that the fence may be following the course of an old stream — something that might explain why that area of prime real estate hadn’t been developed yet.)
Houses just a few steps from the giant post office building. Horse-drawn buggies parked at the curb. People on the sidewalk. What looks like a man with his hands on his hips looking down at a child. Or maybe a dog.
A bustling Commerce Street at the intersection of Ervay, with trollies in the distance.
*
This photograph shows almost exactly the same view as one I posted earlier under the title “Something Like N.Y.” — check out the 1904 version here.
***
The photograph, by Henry Stark, is from the Houston Metropolitan Research Center, Houston Public Library. The resolution is a bit grainy when trying to enlarge the details — to explore the photo for yourself, see it here.
What little is known of Henry Stark can be read in the brief Handbook of Texas bio, here.
For another Henry Stark photo, see the post “Oak Cliff Trolley — 1895,” here.
For other examples of photographs I’ve zoomed in on to reveal unintended vignettes, see here.
All images MUCH larger when clicked.
*
Copyright © 2014 Paula Bosse. All Rights Reserved.
According to 1899 Sanbon Map, the building on the left is identified as “Bookhout Building”.
LikeLike
Thanks, Tom! The Bookhout Building adjoined the Middleton Building — I think the top-knotty part might be the Middleton Building, which Dallas Rediscovered (p. 66) says was built around 1892 and stood until about 1929. The photo in Dallas Rediscovered is a bit more attractive — the view of it in Stark’s photo is just … weird. That middle part facing the viewer just doesn’t “flow” very well. I don’t know….
I actually see this Stark photograph in Dallas Rediscovered, on p. 54, with the caption saying that it was taken from the new Oriental Hotel, with the First Methodist Church spire on the right.
Thanks again for the info, Tom!
LikeLike
You’re right! Upon a closer second examination, the corner building is identified as “Middleton Block” and is 4 floors. The Bookhout is adjacent and is 3 floors.
LikeLike
The 1880 census contains a good bit of additional information on Stark not found in the Handbook’s sketch. In that census he was enumerated as Heinrich Stark, born in Missouri in 1874, and confirms George Stark as an elder brother. His parents were Henry and Eva Stark, both born in Germany.
LikeLike
Thanks, Bob!
LikeLike
[…] For more on Henry Stark, see the previous post “Henry Stark’s ‘Bird’s Eye View of Dallas,'” here. […]
LikeLike
[…] “Henry Stark’s ‘Bird’s Eye View of Dallas’ — 1895/96.” Without question, this is the most popular thing I’ve posted this year. I love this photo. […]
LikeLike
[…] “Henry Stark’s ‘Bird’s Eye View of Dallas’ — 1895/97.” This one was so far ahead of the other posts that there’s no contest in its being the #1 post […]
LikeLike
[…] post “Henry Stark’s ‘Bird’s Eye of Dallas’ — 1895/96″ here (click pictures for larger […]
LikeLike
[…] Hard to see how this one will ever be toppled from its throne, originally posted in 2014: “HENRY STARK’S ‘BIRD’S EYE VIEW OF DALLAS’ — 1895/96.” […]
LikeLike
[…] Another eastward-looking view — from about 1895, when the post office was still pretty new — is here. […]
LikeLike
I can provide a little bit more information about the photographer featured here. Henry Stark was my great-grandfather. He was born Feb. 16, 1874 in St. Louis, MO and died Nov. 2, 1946 in Paducah, KY. He is interred in St. Louis at the St. Matthew Cemetery. He was the son of Heinrich “Henry” Stark (1830-1907) and Eva Dauwel, sometimes spelled Daeuwel (1847-1928). According to census records research, he was indeed the younger brother of George (1872-1946), and also the older brother of John (1876-1886), Katherine aka Katy (1879-1954), and Andrew (1884-1954). He was married first around 1902 to Anna “Annie” H. Mueller (1875-1924), my great-grandmother. They had two children, Henry A. (1902-1981) and Helen M. (1907-2007), my paternal grandmother. In 1929 he married Marie L. Mueller (1871-1939), my great-grandmother’s sister, making my grandmother’s aunt her step-mother. According to his Sep. 12,1918 World War I draft registration, his occupation is listed as “photographer and farming” and it is noted “says he has given up photography and will soon spend entire time farming”. However, the 1920 U.S. Census still has his occupation as “photographer” and industry as “own place” and the 1930 U.S. Census yet still has his occupation as “photographer” and industry as “photography”. I guess farming didn’t work out. That is about all I know about him.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Debbie! I’m glad he continued with his photography!
LikeLike
[…] was located on Main Street — it’s at the far left in this circa-1895 photo detail from this post.) The parlor was owned by John B. Willett and John S. Haney, and in addition to ice cream and […]
LikeLike